I received this mail from many sources but i kept it ignoring because reply was of no use, but finally i decided to answer it although i know currently in our country no one is ready to list
>>Plz clear your mind
Same thing i am asking, please clear your mind and think
>>and think I think you are not aware of GEO...its been funded by usa govt......just think,
He didn't try to prove his point, that how he come to know that geo is funded by the USA, and if in reality GEO is funded by the USA, then The NEWs and JUNG are also being funded by USA, and if all are funded by USA, then whole JUNG media group should be baned, but this is not the case, so it means clearly that GEO is not banned due to this reason.
>>what jew / indian/ American lobby want ... the basic , idea is to promote frustration, and despondence in a nation so >>they start to demoralized .and the future can be mapped as they want to project in the minds of 50 percent Illiterate >>population.. ..that are born muslim ,,,can't read ..but can see why on earth USA is concern with only GEO ,why cnn bbc >>and bush quote GEO?
Now see just to gather more attention and sympathy, my brother added Indian lobby as well, i am amazed why he spared Israeli lobby, my same Question again, if really GEO is working on the agenda of above lobbies then why there news papers are still working.
i couldn't understand, why he categorically "BORN MUSLIM" thing. And one more question arises, USA owned TV channels were also off air for few ours and then again n air, if we are really so much concerned about US and lobbies propaganda then why BBC, CNN and etc are not blacked out totally.
>>why not other tv channels in china ? japan, CUBA ,Indian channel,arab, france ..... ?why only pakistan ??????
What one can say against these kind of argument, because like this there are many examples which contradict many thing in whole world, i am little confuse why he mentioned FRANCE in this list. He should provide us some base of this comparison as well. But we are not concerned what America wants and what CNN shows, we know we wan our media, judiciary and every man should be free, You tell me are you ready to listen, if some one tell you in china every one is chained so you should be as well. Of course you wont listen, but on the other hand if some one says to you in India every one is free so you should be then of course every one will listen. So point is simple we want what good is available.
>>· why geo showed ..peoples body without head ,only fingers parts, people dying after bomb blast ,?does any other channel show these thing????
Why government didn't make a policy to stop this issue, I know few thing
1-all these things all Pakistani channels showed not only GEO then why only GEO is under this allegation.
2-In fact there was a policy, government allowed all TV channels to show the dead bodies of those ho died due to terrorist activities to create more hate to wards Islamist and the proof is media didn't show the dead bodies of LAL Masjid dead, didn't show the bodies of killed in Waziristan and didn't show the bodies of killed in Baluchistan.
But this policy back fired them, when media tried t be independent and showed massacre of 12 may karachi
But this should not happen basically, but there should be certain policy, you can close GEO on the basis of this but without any policy other channels will continue doing so.
As long as it serve government point of view it is OK.... should it be ok, do we need this policy
>>· Just think.. (in India more then 2000 muslims were killed in Gujarat for three months!!!! any 36 hours live coverage of these killing have any one seen on ZEE or star or sony, etc any Indian channels????
First of all There are images i the whole world of thee mascara, but you tell me, you want to know the truth or not.
Tell me if media there had broadcast all things live, the impact could have been lesser, killings f many could have been saved.
But by putting this point my dear brother himself proved my above point that the coverage o 12 may which showed the real face of MQM to the world is one of the main reason of shutting down these media channels.
Because they want t continue this practice.
And as elections are coming, so government and MQM cant allow such bold coverage.
You tell me, what is the harm in live coverage, one can edit recorded coverage to change the facts but one cant transmit his own agenda through live coverage.
So i think and very firmly believe that Live Coverage should be allowed all time and of every thing to show the real truth.
You tell me there is so much confusion that how many died in LAL Masjid operation, as there was no coverage.
A live coverage can solve many things in a seconds.
Only liers and those who want to operate under dark are afraid of live coverage.
>>Babri masjid was destroyed by hindu any live coverage ????
>>nuns in tamil nado of India were burn alive in church and for next 6 hours the church was burning did any Indian or cnn or >>bbc showed that ?????in france 700 cars were burn in one day ) ,,,
i have seen videos of this event myself, so there was a coverage. but again same argument, we should adopt good things from the neighbors or bad things.
As he is saying if in India there was no live coverage then we should not have it as well, but same thing if in India they can burn things then can we as well?
>> · There are 89 separatist movement in India in 2007 .from bihar to Kashmir assam etc..
There are 89 movements in india but they never use aircrafts and gunship helicopters on them why we are doing this?
Why my brother didn't condemn this thing. argument same as above
>> · Do you see on any Indian channel showing ...250 million people sleeping on footpath???? ? · (zee India never >>showed killing of Kashmiris and the attack on GOLDEN TEMPLE ,killing of Sikhs in Indian soil/////// · how many Israeli >>channel show killing by Israeli soldiers ????when they kill Palestinians? ????
Argument same above, but my brother should also tell us how many indian channels were there at the time of golden temple, when Israeli TV dont show his killing we criticize them, Al Jazeera got world famous because they tried to show the facts. Please decide, we should follow what is bad or we should follow what is right. Do we want to keep Baluchistan with us he same way Israel is keeping Palestine or India is keeping Kashmir? If today we wont stand up for the truth then tomorrow your home can be destroyed without any coverage.. think about that as well
>>· have you ever seen Indian president or politician been given GALEE on tv channel during live coverage????
India's one president got drunk and fell on the floor in a way that his man's part was visible from his dhoti and that picture was on air. did we this. in India lok sabha transmission go live on air and in that people can see parliamentarian beating each other, do we have this?
My brother didn't, very smartly, try to bring TEHALKA in a picture. I have seen myself many vulgure, nude and horrifying scene on Indian media, like burning bodies, killings etc......
One more thing did our government catch single person who according to my brother give gaaliiaan to them.
Remaining argument same as above
>>· any killing by irish republican army
Argument same as above and one more thing our PTV shows the torture and dead bodies of kasmiri militants when ever needed, but no comments from my brother over that
>>· 30,000 rape cases in USA do you see on tv????but you see muktaran maee on geo/cnn/bbc
Mukhtaran mai is on air from last 2-3 years why my brother suddenly realized that. remaining argument same as above
>> · Why geo was not concerned with benazir wealth and property?? And Nawaz Sharif property??
I think this argument is totally unnecessary, they have shown this, but i agree not too much, but GEO didn't even showed the property of Musharraf and PML(Q) as well. Did PTV shown this? if this is the reason then why PTV is not shut down.
>>WHO is GEO ???? just think ???? they telecast a false news about emergency and stock market crashed in Pakistan .
There was no false news about emergency the false news was about Musharraf detention. But at that time GEO was off air. stopping Rumors is responsibility of government or GEO. My brother didt tell us when last time stock market crashed was that because of GEO as well, no But when GEO/CJ/other channels tried to highlight who are the responsible one by one all sacked and that is why stock market again crashed. This is the government who is not catching the culprits even after their disclosure and that is why things are happening again and again.
>>· do you know Kamran khan was getting RS 25 lakh per month ,
>>· do you know DR shahid masood, was a member of NSF student party ( a political left wing student party against >>Pakistan and Islamic forces.. He use to sit around girls all day long ) with RS 22 lakh per month and home in dubai and >>karachi ,,multiple visa ...same amount been paid to hamid meer editor ausaf..even nadia khan with Rs 6 lakh per >>month..
>>Such huge amount just to for free ???????
My brother didn't mention how he came to know about these things. I live in Dubai and i am earning 200,000, am i also American sponsored. i know you must be thinking Is it only baseless blame game, yes now it seems and proved to me, it is.
In India (as my brother Love to talk about them) Karan johar is taking 5,00,000,00(5 cr) for tv show, is that also American sponsored.
Shah rukh and Amitabh took millions for their shows, were those American sponsored as well.
Is NSF banned in Pakistan? a political activist in the end became a surgeon, i think one can easily access how active he could be in that party. For fun in my college i joined PSF and today i hate PPP.... i created one party with friends as well
>>· when they were not able to broadcast the 8 hour cricket match they said they lost 1 billion rupee ,and just imagine without any money just for free they were broadcasting judge activity in peoples party car for free
Wahhh, iss saadgi pay kaun naa mur jaaye ae khudda , they bought the rights of series for some thing around 15 million$, and Of course they had to pay even if they are not allowed to telecast, i read that they are bearing loss of 2 million$ a day.
>> ], Nawaz sharif for free and benazir for free..all... 36 hour coverage just for free ???????????? ?????by a private >>channel !!!!!!!!!!!! !
What some one can give answer of such thing, they have air time paid for month, they can broadcast any thing in that time and to get more audience they need more credibility, one need to show things of public interest only then people will see the advertisement.
Let me tell you my own example... i hate movie Khuda kay liyay created by GEO and every time i see its advertisement my BP goes up, but i am compelled to see it because i have to watch Capital Talk and Meray Mutabiq etc.
But this kind of argument has shown the mental ability of the writer and yes he has really tried to prove that Pakistani which are BORN MUSLIM are idiots.
>>· 50 percent Indian dramas on geo and 25 percent with mix cast (Indian and Pakistani) and Indian films (which are ban >>in Pakistani cinema are been broadcasted by geo) movie like "khuda key liyaeh" an issue of so that people can play with >>Islam and its culture ...were telecasted.. ...alim online where mr amir liaqat sitting in grave and dramatizing islam ..he >>translated the dua of imam kaba and .broadcasted by his name on tv ....
these are the points i am really agreed with, and i like to added program named GHAMDI as well, but my brother please tell me Khudda Kay Liyay got aired in whole Pakistan even though India refused to put this on air because they thought that Muslims in India wont like the movie, but Government of Pakistan which was co-sponsored in this movie put this movie in cinema, my brother please tell me Why government of Pakistan sponsored such movie and dint try to block its screening in Pakistan.
My brother also didn't tell us the Amir Liaqat was Federal Cabinet minister in this government, My brother also didn't try to tell us that any of these issues were or will be discussed in PEMRA.
No, Government just to justify his act are advertising all bad things so people from all segments of society will get a point each and will favor government and condemn GEO.
But my brother Tell me, dont you know, through PEMRA ordinance government only want to stop only those programs who are criticizing government.
All programs and agenda against Islam and culture is allowed and will continue in same way.
>>Audience 50% jahil people in Pakistan geo did not showed any good news like islamabad peshwar motorway but instead >>it showed dead people in karachi ....they never discuss 5.1 billion dollar of oil refinery in pakistan instead they showed >>beheading of Pakistani people... never discuss why America is telling musharf to take his uniform ????/why usa is >>interfering in our business..!! !!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!! itna jhoot bolo key ..log sum jahen kuch to succch ho ga .. Rasuul pak >>said.budd.GUMMANee nahi karna chahiyeh and he also said for a muslim to be liar is without any enquire /investigation >>he communicate ... A COUNTRY WHERE 60 percent of population cannot read and never been to school media must not be >>free ......
Yes my brother, in the end you really tried to prove that Pakistani are idiots and they can be de-tracked by your such points.
PTV is showing all goods of government and GEO/other private channels were trying to show the other picture.
to balance the picture.
If their are good things happening in Pakistan then every one will come to know themselves and they wont believe in lies of any private channels.
they will only believe if they wont find it in front of their eyes.
You tell me if all the channels of Pakistan start saying all roads of the country have been rebuilt and the road in front of my house is broken, the credibility of all will be gone.
Why People dont listen PTV, because PTV dont show truth.
You cant stop/hide truth by stopping one/all TV channels.
I am not on payroll of GEO, But i know there are many things which need improvement but the way Musharraf want to fix things is totally wrong.
If he really want to make things better then He should use his brain instead of his dundaa.