Search
 
Write
 
Forums
 
Login
"Let there arise out of you a band of people inviting to all that is good enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong; they are the ones to attain felicity".
(surah Al-Imran,ayat-104)
Image Not found for user
User Name: Noman
Full Name: Noman Zafar
User since: 1/Jan/2007
No Of voices: 2195
 
 Views: 1600   
 Replies: 1   
 Share with Friend  
 Post Comment  

The Long Road to Chaos in Pakistan

Tyler Hicks/The New York Times

GUN MARKET Near the Khyber Pass is Peshawar, the administrative center for the tribal areas where the Taliban regroups and rearms.

Published: September 27, 2008

Hours after a truck bomber slew 53 people last weekend at the Marriott Hotel in Islamabad, Pakistan, the country's interior minister laid responsibility for the attack on Taliban militants holed up in the Federally Administered Tribal Areas, or FATA, the remote, wild region that straddles the border with Afghanistan.

Pool photo by Aamir Qureshi

BATTLE A Pakistani offensive in Bajaur.

"All roads lead to FATA," Interior Minister Rehman Malik said.

If the past is any guide, Mr. Malik's statement is almost certainly correct.

But what Mr. Malik did not say was that those same roads, if he chose to follow them, would very likely loop back to Islamabad itself.

The chaos that is engulfing Pakistan appears to represent an especially frightening case of strategic blowback, one that has now begun to seriously undermine the American effort in Afghanistan. Tensions over Washington's demands that the militants be brought under control have been rising, and last week an exchange of fire erupted between American and Pakistani troops along the Afghan border. So it seems a good moment to take a look back at how the chaos has developed.

It was more than a decade ago that Pakistan's leaders began nurturing the Taliban and their brethren to help advance the country's regional interests. Now they are finding that their home-schooled militants have grown too strong to control. No longer content to just cross into Afghanistan to kill American soldiers, the militants have begun to challenge the government itself. "The Pakistanis are truly concerned about their whole country unraveling," said a Western military official, speaking on condition of anonymity because the matter is sensitive.

That is a horrifying prospect, especially for Pakistan's fledgling civilian government, its first since 1999. The country has a substantial arsenal of nuclear weapons. The tribal areas, which harbor thousands of Taliban militants, are also believed to contain Al Qaeda's senior leaders, including Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahri.

It's all the greater a paradox, then, that the Taliban militias now threatening the stability of Pakistan owe their survival "” and much of their present strength "” to a succession of Pakistani governments that continues to the present day.

The origins of the present predicament date to 1994, when Pakistan, unnerved by the bloody civil war that had engulfed Afghanistan following the Soviet Union's departure five years earlier, turned to a group of fierce but moralistic Afghan tribesman who had won a string of victories. They called themselves "the students" "” in Arabic and Pashto, the Taliban. Sensing an opportunity, the Pakistani government, led then by Benazir Bhutto, threw its support behind them. Aided by Pakistani money, supplies and military advisers, the Taliban swept across Afghanistan, entering the capital in 1996.

It was the same group of men "” under the Taliban, women were stripped of nearly all their rights "” whom the Americans overthrew when they invaded Afghanistan after Sept. 11, 2001.

Which brings us to the current crisis. After the 9/11 terrorist attacks, then-President Pervez Musharraf publicly promised to break with the Taliban. For that, Pakistan was rewarded with nearly $10 billion in American aid. But over the years, something else happened: whatever President Musharraf said in public, the military and intelligence services over which he presided demonstrated every intention of strengthening the Taliban, who fled en masse to the borderlands after their expulsion from Kabul in November 2001.

Over the years, the evidence has been too obvious to ignore. In 2002, for instance, Mr. Musharraf ordered the arrest of some 2,000 suspected militants "” many of whom had trained in Pakistani-sponsored camps. Weeks later, without fanfare, he released nearly all of them.

Likewise, after 9/11, President Musharraf promised to rein in the estimated 25,000 private Islamic schools "” many of them incubators of Islamic militants "” but never took the slightest steps to do so.

The most glaring example came last July, when operatives of Pakistan's Inter Services Intelligence, or I.S.I., were said to have helped fighters under Serajuddin Haqqani, a Taliban commander, bomb the Indian Embassy in Kabul. An Indian defense attaché was among 54 people killed, and American officials said there was overwhelming evidence pointing to I.S.I. involvement. "It was sort of this 'aha' moment," an American official said.

The single most persuasive explanation for Pakistan's continued involvement with the Taliban is the country's obsession with India. Pakistan and India have fought three major wars since they broke with the British Empire in 1947, and the rivalry lives on. India has allied itself closely with the Afghan government of Hamid Karzai. In 2006, for instance, a senior I.S.I. official told a New York Times reporter that he regarded Mr. Haqqani as an I.S.I. intelligence asset. Mr. Haqqani, an Afghan Pashtun, is one of the Taliban's most senior commanders battling the Americans. His father, Jalalhuddin, is a longtime associate of Osama bin Laden. The Haqqanis are thought to be overseeing operations from the border territories.

But while the Pakistanis have been primarily interested in using the Taliban to exert their influence inside Afghanistan, the Taliban have expanded their ambitions to include Pakistan itself. A turning point came in the summer of 2007, when Pakistani troops stormed the Red Mosque, where Islamic militants had gathered in the capital. The gun battle killed nearly 100 people. Taliban militants launched a wave of suicide bombings around the country, and Baitullah Mehsud formed Tariq-i-Taliban Pakistan, an umbrella organization of several Taliban groups, and declared war on the Pakistani government. Since then, Taliban militias have expanded their reach beyond the FATA areas to include much of the neighboring Northwest Frontier Province.

Which brings us, finally, to the Americans. Concerned about the growth of the Taliban inside Pakistan "” and about the growing losses of American soldiers in Afghanistan "” American officials have pressed Pakistani leaders to crush the militants in their bases inside the tribal areas. The Pakistanis have launched a series of offensives, and all of them have ended with the militants stronger than ever. It may be that the Pakistan Army is too inept to destroy the Taliban, but there is abundant evidence suggesting that at least some elements of the army do not want to do that.

"I would not rule out the possibility that explicit deals were made by the military," the American military official said.

With the arrival of Pakistan's new civilian government last February, the situation seems more intractable than ever. The government, now led by Yousaf Raja Gilani, is still hugely dependent on America. The Bush administration, in turn, has continued to press Mr. Gilani for military operations against the militants in the tribal areas.

And there's the rub. Each time Mr. Gilani has sent troops into those areas, he has succeeded only in sparking the outcries of his fellow Pakistanis, who are growing increasingly bitter toward what they see as the Bush administration's overbearing ways. The attack on the Marriott, for instance, came on the heels of a recent Pakistani offensive in the Bajaur tribal agency. While there is no direct evidence that the attack on the Marriott was launched in retaliation for that offensive, many Pakistanis certainly saw it that way.

Meanwhile, as the Taliban has grown stronger, the Bush Administration has stepped up its own military operations inside Pakistan, taking the extraordinary step this month of landing helicopter-borne soldiers in a village in South Waziristan to strike a suspected militant hideout. The military strike set off tremors of anti-American anger; Pakistani officials, buffeted by domestic criticism, have promised to use force against any future American incursions.

What does the future hold? Some American analysts worry that the fledgling civilian government in Pakistan won't be able to survive the cross-currents of American pressure and the anti-American anger it stimulates. For their part, American officials have been silent on whether they will attempt more cross-border raids, but privately they say the situation in the tribal areas is contributing to the deterioration of the situation in Afghanistan. Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said this month that while he was sure that victory in Afghanistan was possible, "I'm not convinced we're winning it" there now.

One thing seems a good bet: that the fires and deaths that consumed the Marriot Hotel last weekend will not be the last.

Dexter Filkins, who has covered the Afghanistan and Iraq wars for The New York Times, is the author of "The Forever War" (Knopf).

 Reply:   Anti-U.S. views fuel polio growth in Pakistan
Replied by(Noman) Replied on (23/Oct/2008)
Pakistan - With her face partly hidden behind a traditional black cloak, Salma Amir follows her daughter Farah's every movement while tightly gripping the 15-month-old toddler's back. Farah'

Ayesha Akram-Nasir, Chronicle Foreign Service

Saturday, October 4, 2008

Lahore

Pakistan - With her face partly hidden behind a traditional black cloak, Salma Amir follows her daughter Farah's every movement while tightly gripping the 15-month-old toddler's back. Farah's sticklike legs fail to straighten as she clasps her mother's hands and laughs with glee.

Salma Amir picks up her daugher Farah in a squatter settlement on the outskirts of Lahore, Pakistan. The 15-month-old toddler has polio. (By Ayesha Akram-Nasir / Special to The Chronicle)


"I didn't know what's wrong with her," said Amir, who lives with her husband in a squatter settlement. "She developed fever and the next day her legs refused to straighten out."

At a government hospital, doctors told Amir that her daughter had polio.

To date, Farah is the lone case of polio in this city of 10 million inhabitants. But health officials fear the polio virus is re-emerging across Pakistan. It is especially serious, they say, in the lawless tribal North West Frontier Province along the border with Afghanistan where the Islamic fundamentalist Taliban rule and many families have refused vaccinations on religious grounds.

"The situation is worrisome, very, very worrisome," said Dr. Whaeed Khan, health director for the city of Peshawar. "Even previously polio-free cities are becoming infected."

In 2007, the World Health Organization recorded 32 cases of polio in Pakistan, up from 28 in 2005. Between January and August, 31 more cases have been recorded, with one-third in the tribal areas.

Since a door-to-door immunization program began in 2001, tens of millions of children have been vaccinated or given polio drops, according to health authorities. But in tribal areas, radical Islamic clerics such as Maulana Fazlullah have convinced residents that U.S.-manufactured polio drops are designed to sterilize Pakistanis and reduce the Muslim population.

"If the Pakistani government wants to give our children these drops, then they have to manufacture them in this country," said Muslim Khan, a spokesman for Tehrik-e-Taliban, Fazlullah's militant organization.

Health authorities say polio vaccines used in Pakistan are produced in WHO-accredited laboratories not only in the United States but in Japan, Belgium and India. Pakistan has no such laboratory.

Kahn says recent air strikes in tribal areas have also contributed to residents refusing to allow vaccinations for their children. Since Aug. 13, there have been at least seven reported U.S. missile strikes, as well as a ground force operation, in tribal territories.

"Due to the security situation in these areas there is a lot of resentment against America," said Kahn. "The perception that this vaccine is a U.S. product holds strong in these areas, leading to refusals" to accept vaccinations.

Khan also noted that Fazlullah's sermons have stressed that those who become crippled or die from polio are martyrs. The vaccine is considered haram, or that which is forbidden for Muslims.

"There are other diseases also - like hepatitis, typhoid, etc. Why is everyone concentrating on polio?" asked Kahn. "See, this is an American conspiracy."

Tehrik-e-Taliban's opposition and a worsening security situation have caused government vaccination teams to stay out of tribal territories. In the Swat area alone, some 160,000 children have gone without immunizations, according to the state Expanded Program on Immunization, or EPI.

"It just wasn't possible to gain access to those areas," said Muqeem Khilji, an EPI spokesman.

Khilji says that aside from conspiracy theories, religious beliefs can also play a role in keeping children from being vaccinated. "Some parents say it's un-Islamic to vaccinate their children because it's akin to tampering with the will of Allah," said Wahaeed Khan, a former EPI official.

Other EPI officials say many tribal communities refuse to cooperate with vaccination programs until the state agrees to a road or sewer project in return.

To be sure, many religious leaders support the government vaccination campaign. The EPI team has obtained fatwas, or religious declarations, from such renowned Islamic scholars as Maulana Fazl-u-Rehman and Qazi Hussain Ahmed. But in such tribal areas as Swat, Bajaur Agency and Kurram Agency, militant clerics like Maulana Fazlullah are more influential in shaping local opinions, health workers say.

With the government rapidly losing control over tribal areas, EPI volunteers fear being beaten and kidnapped, says Khan. In 2006, two campaign workers were shot dead on their way back from trying to convince a local council to support the state vaccination drive.

"In June, four of our volunteers were kidnapped and kept for two days," said Kahn.

Joint Secretary of Health Azam Saleem predicts that Pakistan will be a polio-free country by 2012, a date some health workers suggest may be too optimistic.

"To end polio in this country, we need to change people's attitudes," said Whaeed Kahn.

KEY FACTS ABOUT POLIO

-- Polio is a highly infectious disease caused by a virus. It invades the nervous system and can cause total paralysis in a matter of hours. The virus enters the body through the mouth and multiplies in the intestine.

-- Initial symptoms are fever, fatigue, headache, vomiting, stiffness in the neck and pain in limbs.

-- The virus mainly affects children under 5.

-- One in 200 infections leads to irreversible paralysis usually in the legs.

-- In 2007, more than 400 million children were immunized in 27 countries.

-- Polio cases have decreased by more than 99 percent since 1988, from an estimated 350,000 cases in more than 125 endemic countries to 1,997 reported cases in 2006.

-- Between 2003 and 2005, 25 previously polio-free countries were reinfected.

-- Only four countries in the world remain endemic for the disease - Nigeria, Pakistan, India and Afghanistan - and Nigeria leads the world with 578 cases in 2008.

Source: World Health Organization

E-mail Ayesha Akram-Nasir at foreign@sfchronicle.com.


 
Please send your suggestion/submission to webmaster@makePakistanBetter.com
Long Live Islam and Pakistan
Site is best viewed at 1280*800 resolution